Agate Bay Properties - Carnelian Bay, California

Jason E.

Our stay with Agate Bay Properties was nothing short of incredible! From the moment we booked, Sean was communicative, friendly, and went above and beyond to ensure our trip was seamless. The property itself was pristine—spotlessly clean, beautifully furnished, and equipped with all the amenities we needed for a relaxing getaway.

What truly stood out was the attention to detail. From cozy linens to a well-stocked kitchen, every aspect of the home was thoughtfully prepared. The location was perfect—just a short drive to the slopes, with gorgeous views and easy access to hiking trails and the lake.

Sean’s local recommendations for dining and activities made our trip even more memorable. It’s rare to find hosts who genuinely care about their guests’ experiences, but Sean and the Agate Bay team truly delivered.

We can’t recommend them highly enough and are already looking forward to our next visit to Agate Bay!

Alexis W.

My pup and I had a wonderful stay at one of the Agate Bay properties in Carnelian Bay. It was a beautiful cabin in a great location right across from the lake. The unit had ample desk and table space along with good wifi, which was perfect for WFH. Most importantly, the host was extremely responsive and helpful. I accidentally locked myself out when using the side door SUPER early in the morning taking my dog out to potty (be sure to check that the actual door handle isn't locked if you use that entry!), and had to call the INCREDIBLY kind host (Sean) who was able to have my hero (Lisa) come by and let me in. I felt horrible and was so extremely thankful for their prompt response. Highly recommend!

Evan W.

Sean Gray and his team were extremely helpful. Highly educated and skilled in sales and property management. We will use Sean and Agate Bay Properties for all current and future real estate needs!! Five stars across the board. Thanks again!!!

Carol H.

Agate Bay Properties is the best and easiest way to book a vacation, and the rentals are in the best location in Tahoe!!! They have amazing customer service, and I cant wait to come back!

Ricky H.

We always rent a home from Agate Bay Properties when we visit Tahoe from Maui. They have the best customer service and the properties are always top notch! Aloha

Mark B.

We originally booked a cabin for 3 nights with Agate Bay Properties through Airbnb but due to the Lake Tahoe fires, evacuations, and shutdowns, could not make our reservation. Sean was professional, understanding, responsive, and accommodating throughout the entire situation.

With the tons of horror stories of hosts putting money above ethics and visitors, working with Sean and Agate was a breath of fresh air and very much appreciated. Would book again 10/10.

Thanks again, Sean.

Alan F.

Great selection of rental properties within Agate Bay, many with access to the Agate Bay Sun Club (pool and snack bar) and the Agate Bay private pier. We've been renting summer vacation places from them for years. Highly recommended.

Nick A.

Beware of renting the Bagley cabin at 5754 Victoria Road in Carnelian Bay. Had a big problem dealing with the property manager Sean, but according to him the bigger issue lies with the owner who decides what compensation you get after a bear breaks into your rental. I had booked this property for 5 nights at the end of August, which is dog friendly as well, and we had a bear break into the house in the middle of the night thru a half open window. This area is no stranger to bears, as all the houses have bear boxes for the trash to go in and it is not recommended to leave food in your car since they might break in. Luckily no one was hurt as the bear left the house, though it did try and come back thru the back door. I let Sean know what happened the next day and he just had a no harm no foul attitude before cutting our conversation short saying he would call me right back. He did not, so after 5 hours I called him back and he had the same attitude, not offering to comp a nites stay or move us to a different property. I had to convince him to do so. In the past we had stayed at a different property and we had the water shut off for a few hours to fix the plumbing, of which we were comped a nites stay no questions asked for what is a MINOR inconvenience. Having a bear break into our rental is far beyond a minor inconvenience. Either way, I received an email the next day showing a refund of $100, not even a 1/3 of a nites rate which was $352. It took a couple of days to get ahold of Sean to voice my displeasure and he explained that the owners decide what to refund. So apparently a lot of the blame is due to the owner of the house not caring at all. He told me he would talk to them again and if he couldn't convince the owner for additional refund he would take it out of his own commission. Fast forward a month later and I have yet to hear from Sean or receive an additional refund. I call both numbers and email him for a week before I hear anything. He responds "who's this?", needless to say it was infuriating. He obviously was dodging me from the beginning and only caved once I called him out on it. So eventually a week later I get an additional refund of $150 apparently from his commission. All in all I got refunded $250 out of the $1760 I spent for 5 nites which as I said comes to $352 a nite. The whole ordeal was a nightmare from beginning to end. I will continue to vacation in Lake Tahoe, but will steer clear of Sean and Agate Bay properties if I can.