RE/MAX At Barnegat Bay - Toms River - Toms River, New Jersey

Michele L.

Never Use Another Realtor. My husband and I were on the fence about selling and buying but I found this home on Zillow and reached out to the realtor unbeknownst it was Mike. He called me instantly and although he wasn't the listing agent he worked tirelessly to get us into see this house that is now our home. He met us here every time we asked so we could look and double check things. It didn't matter if it was a Tuesday or a Saturday he was here. I honestly can't say enough about Mike. He's very honest, he knows when to give his opinion and when not to but he's always on your side. You will be in good hands with Mike. I would recommend Mike any day of the week and know you'll be in good hands.

Allison S.

The Best Decision We Made: A Patient, Kind, and Now Lifelong Friend in Real Estate. Working with Mike was an absolute blessing throughout what turned out to be an extremely tedious process on our end. From start to finish, he was not only patient and kind but genuinely invested in helping us find the perfect multigenerational home. He always took the time to answer our questions, explain the details, and ensure we felt confident in every step we were taking. His unwavering support made a complex journey feel manageable, and we truly cannot imagine having worked with anyone else.

What stood out the most was his genuine compassion and understanding of our family’s unique needs. He wasn’t just focused on making a sale; he was committed to helping us find a home that would work for all of us. His dedication was evident, even when the process became overwhelming.

We are beyond grateful for his guidance, professionalism, and warmth. He’s not just a realtor to us now; he’s become a friend for life. If you’re looking for someone who truly cares about your needs, I can’t recommend Mike enough.

Valerie T.

Great experience!! After looking for awhile we decided it was time to switch realtors. We contacted Michael Butterworth and he asked what was our wants, needs, location and he went to work. We felt confident finding someone who listens.
He directed his attention to finding us our house. He’s a great communicator. He answered all of our questions and concerns. Always showed up on time.
We truly can't say enough about his professionalism and knowledge of the market and his business. He found us our house in 3 weeks! It was truly a pleasure working with Mike. I would recommend him in a minute. If you're looking for someone who has YOUR best interest in mind, you must contact Michael Butterworth.
Thank you Mike for finding us our shore house!

Matthew D.

Mike is the best!
Whatever we needed Mike made sure to take care of us.
Everything went smooth and easy, it was a real pleasure working with him.
Thanks again Mike!

Sylvia O.

Mike is an amazing real estate agent! Mike was professional from the start, when we started looking for houses, we were getting calls from realtors who are kind of treating us like a game. Mike was the only person to actually reach out and try to communicate to us like we were humans. He was always very professional and honest with us, and on top of it he was very accommodating to our schedule, and when we were available to look. We ended up finding a house that was somewhere we didn’t even think to look, and he did such a great job walking us through the whole application, making an offer, all the way to closing. He recommended us some companies all the way down to the people who did the home inspection, and he steered us right every step of the way. If you’re looking for someone that cares, Mike is your guy 🙂

Matthew W.

Amazing Experience. My wife and I were first time home buyers, and were unfamiliar with the process and what to expect. Mike was able to take us through each step of the process from start to finish, providing guidance and advice along the way. He made everything simple and easy to understand, and helped us purchase the perfect home in our desired location. Mike was professional, responsive, and extremely helpful. We feel truly blessed to have worked with Mike as our agent and cannot recommended him highly enough!

Ryan A.

Wonderful experience with Mike! . Mike was everything I could have asked for in a real estate agent. From the beginning, he worked with me to set realistic goals given my budget and worked diligently to quickly identify listings that might appeal to me. He always made himself available for tours and made himself available for personal calls. as well. After falling short a few times on some places I’d really hoped to win out on, Mike kept me motivated even in this tough market. Soon enough, I would find the place I will call home for the next several years as I enter the next phase of my life. I cannot recommend Mike enough!

conti S. L.

Best in the business . The headline doesn't lie..I have used Mike for numerous real estate transactions and he never disappoints. He goes above and beyond for his clients and is also your best friend for life after close! I found this home and Mike immediately went to work securing the deal and making it happen.